Jump to content








Photo - - - - -

Healthy Food vs Good Tasting Food: Paula Deen Controversy

Posted by Brendita, in Life of Brendita, Health & Fitness 19 January 2012 · 404 views

I can’t believe that the first month of 2012 is nearly over! My mother always told me that time goes by faster as you get older and she sure was right.

I’ve been eating breakfast every day, as planned. I get a few pieces of fruit from the “Fruit guy” near my job, but I still need some more bulk in my diet, so I’m going to start cooking/eating more beans.

Speaking of my food, I’ve been following the Paula Deen story and I’m a little disturbed by the whole thing. If you’re not familiar with the story, this is it in a nutshell: Paula is a TV chef and she’s famous for using lots of butter, lard and sugar. She cooks what is most commonly referred to as “comfort food” or “Southern Cuisine”. She was diagnosed with Type II diabetes 3 years ago, but she only admitted it to the public recently. People keep asking her when she plans on admitting that it was her cooking/eating habits that caused her to develop diabetes. They’re also “demanding” or “strongly suggesting” that she change her cooking style to include healthier foods. When I say “they” I’m referring to talk show hosts, news interviewers, etc.

Type 2 diabetes is a disease that develops, no one if born with it. It is caused by a combination of things, including being overweight, eating a diet that’s high in fat and sugar and not getting any (or enough) exercise. It is preventable and usually reversible.

I was watching The View yesterday and the ladies got into a heated discussion about the topic. When it was suggested that Paula should demonstrate how to make healthier meals and desserts one of the hosts said something along the lines of “She can’t because she’s known for cooking food that tastes good”.
When I hear people complaining about not wanting to eat healthy because healthy food doesn’t taste good, it makes me want to scream! I’m not a health fanatic by any means but I know that if I dine on fast food, soda and Hostess Twinkies, I’m going to have to pay the price for it eventually. There are plenty of ways to cook healthy AND tasty food. Most chefs on TV have changed their cooking styles in favour of more healthful cooking methods and techniques. That’s why Paula’s cooking style stood out so much.

Anthony Bourdain, another celebrity chef said this to TV Guide about Paula Deen "When your signature dish is hamburger in between a doughnut, and you've been cheerfully selling this stuff knowing all along that you've got Type 2 Diabetes. ... It's in bad taste if nothing else”

I saw Paula Deen deep fry a stick of butter :wacko: !!! The fact that she waited 3 years before admitting that she was diabetic is very telling. She defended her method of cooking for years by saying that a person can eat anything he or she wants to, as long as it’s done in moderation. It would be nice if she tried to lighten up her old recipes and make them a little healthier. I just don’t see how she will be able to continue to have the same kind of cooking show, with all of that fattening, artery clogging food, while she’s acting as the spokesperson for diabetes medication. She has been saying that she doesn’t plan on making any major changes to her cooking style.

Actually, the reason she “came out” is that she agreed to be the spokesperson for a diabetes drug called Victoza. I didn’t hear this until about 2 days after the story broke. I wish she would have decided to promote healthier cooking and eating, instead of promoting a pill as a quick-fix.




OMG....I am so outraged by your entry regarding diabetes/Paula Deen! How can you be so judgemental?!? I AM A DIABETIC, type 2. Thank you for judging my eating habits. For your information, diabetes is not caused by "eating fat and sugar"..... it it caused by a long list of factors, including family genetics, hormone imbalances (insulin, itself, it a hormone) sometimes by pregnancy and insulin resistance among other things. It is not always preventable and reversible. Please get your medical facts straight before you try and "educate" us. There are many, many diabetics with an acceptable BMI...who look healthy and are, in fact, very unhealthy. It is not caused by being fat, and clogged arteries are a completely different health issue than diabetes. Get off your high horse and show some compassion by those affected by a serious disease. It took me over two years to understand and accept my diagnosis...it may have just taken Ms. Deen a bit longer to come to terms with hers. Hopefully, SHE can truly and truthfully educate people and use her celebrity status to deliver a medically intelligent message.
  • Report
There’s a nice way to say pretty much any thing, but I see you chose to take another approach. Well, all righty then.

"For your information, diabetes is not caused by "eating fat and sugar"....."

It’s a fact that a lack of exercise and the consumption of fatty foods and high sugar can contribute to a person developing Type II diabetes. I didn't say that these were the only causes. If you're going to quote me, do so correctly. Gestational and Type I Diabetes are not preventable or reversible, but Type II is indeed preventable and in many cases reversible.

"clogged arteries are a completely different health issue than diabetes"

People who are pre-diabetic or have already developed Type II diabetes usually have very high cholesterol levels, so despite what you say, there is a link between clogged arteries and diabetes.

"Get off your high horse and show some compassion by those affected by a serious disease."

I don't believe anything I wrote could be interpreted as uncompassionate. I know and care for people with Types I and II Diabetes and it wasn't my intention to sound uncaring.

"How can you be so judgemental?!?"

I didn't judge anyone: I was stating my view and opinion.

"Please get your medical facts straight before you try and "educate" us."

I don't state facts without either knowing them or researching them using peer reviewed documentation.

"Hopefully, SHE can truly and truthfully educate people and use her celebrity status to deliver a medically intelligent message."

(MEEEOW!!) I’ve been a fan of Paula Deen for many years. I hope that she’s able to raise awareness about diabetes. I wish that she used her celebrity as a chef to show that a person can change his or her eating habits to manage/treat diabetes, instead of using her status to promote medication.
  • Report
My mom developed Type II diabetes which she was managing with medication. Then she lost about 20 pounds over a year and half and she no longer needs the meds.
  • Report

Newsletter

Search My Blog

You must be logged in to post a comment.